When is qbase+, GenEx or REST better for you?
Each was written by people who know qPCR, and the methods in them are published.
| You classify samples on many genes | GenEx: PCA, self-organizing maps, clustering and heat maps, with NormFinder beside geNorm |
|---|---|
| You plan replicates from a pilot | GenEx: a nested ANOVA shows how much variance each step adds |
| Your lab works under GxP | MultiD sells GenEx GxP, an edition for regulated labs |
| You need one quick two-group answer | REST 2009: free, with a randomization test that assumes no normal distribution |
| A qbase+ study must stay unchanged | Finish it in the install you have; the workspace imports when you’re ready |
| You work in R already | The packages there have a comparison of their own |
Has your analysis outgrown one computer?
- The analysis lives on one licensed computer. A colleague waits for it, or does the work again.
- The plate starts in a spreadsheet. Layout and volumes are typed again into the cycler: none of the three documents a step that does it, as of October 26, 2026.
- Your study spans several plates. REST 2009 takes one table of Cq values, with no step between runs.
- A reviewer asks which settings made a figure. The project file sat on a laptop that has since been reassigned.
- It runs on one operating system. REST 2009 is a Windows program that needs .NET Framework 2.0.
Side by side
| What you need | qbase+ | GenEx | REST 2009 | Clarida |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Design | ||||
Planning the replicatesDetails | AdviceSample maximization, three inter-run calibrators, a geNorm pilot first | Stronger: From a pilotA nested ANOVA shows the variance each step adds, to plan replicates | Not documentedNot in the user guide | You set themReplicates per reaction, by you or a preset |
The plate layoutDetails | After the runWells named in a run editor; a layout copies to other plates | Not documentedNot in the product pages | Per geneCq entered per gene, not per well | Stronger: GeneratedBy your lab’s rules, in blocks for a multichannel pipette; the free Plate editor writes a QuantStudio or CFX setup file |
| Execute | ||||
Mixes and pipettingDetails | Not documentedNot in the manual | Not documentedNot in the product pages | Not documentedNot in the user guide | Stronger: Worked outEach mix with its surplus, then a guide to fill the plate |
| Import | ||||
The run comes inDetails | Cq tablesFrom 32 named instruments, plus RDML and two generic formats | Text exportsThe text files cyclers export | PastedCq per gene and group, or Rotor-Gene Q results | Run filesFour makers’ files with their curves, RDML, or a Cq table; checked against your plate |
| Analyze | ||||
Cq from the raw curvesDetails | Imports CqNo raw curves in the manual | Imports CqFrom instrument export files | Typed inCq pasted per gene | Stronger: Built inA curve fit per well by default, a threshold or the second-derivative maximum; the instrument’s Cq kept |
EfficiencyDetails | Per targetTyped, or from a dilution series, optionally per run, with its error | Built inEfficiency correction in preprocessing | Per geneFrom a standard curve, or typed; 100% if left empty | Per targetFrom your dilution series, pooled over runs, with its error |
Several reference genesDetails | SeveralEvery marked gene combined; global mean and custom factors too | Built inNormalization to selected reference genes | SeveralCombined by geometric mean | SeveralCombined by geometric mean, or the global mean |
Which reference genes are stableDetails | geNormM and V, plus an expert reading of how many genes to use | Two methodsgeNorm and NormFinder | Not documentedNot in the user guide | Two methodsgeNorm and NormFinder, side by side in one experiment |
Several runsDetails | CalibratorsOne or more per gene, applied after normalization, with its error | Built inInterplate calibration | One tableOne table of Cq values, no step between runs | Built inA run effect fitted across all runs, with its error |
Error carried to the resultDetails | Built inReplicates, efficiency, normalization factor and calibration | Not documentedNot in the product pages | IntervalsBootstrap confidence intervals on the ratio | Built inFrom the replicates and the efficiency through to the normalized result |
StatisticsDetails | WizardGuides you to a t-test, ANOVA, rank test, correlation or Cox model | Stronger: ExtensiveTests with multiple-testing correction, plus PCA, clustering, heat maps and neural networks | Two groupsRandomization test, no normality assumed | Common testst-tests, ANOVA with post-hoc comparisons, rank-based methods and correlation; adjusted p-values |
| Report | ||||
Results outDetails | Tables, RDMLExcel and CSV tables, charts as SVG or PDF, projects in RDML | Not documentedExport not in the product pages | Table, plotsBox plots saved by right-click | Report, Excel, RDMLA PDF or HTML report with each table as CSV; the experiment in your Excel notebook; RDML 1.3 |
| Throughout | ||||
The whole lab in one placeDetails | Per computerWindows, Mac and Linux; one user per workspace | Per userA two-year license key for one user | Per computerA Windows program | Stronger: SharedOne workspace in the browser, with named settings sets the lab shares, on a paid plan |
A year laterDetails | Your workspaceOn your computer, backed up at each upgrade; Clarida imports it | Not documentedNot in the product pages | Not documentedNot in the user guide | Stronger: FrozenA saved analysis never changes, even after an update; earlier versions of the design and settings can be restored |
marks the stronger tool for that need.
In short
| Stronger in GenEx | Planning the replicates · Statistics |
|---|---|
| Stronger in Clarida | The plate layout · Mixes and pipetting · Cq from the raw curves · The whole lab in one place · A year later |
| A draw | The run comes in · Efficiency · Several reference genes · Which reference genes are stable · Several runs · Error carried to the result · Results out |
How do you check it on a reported run?
- Take a result you have already reported. Import the run behind it, or the whole qbase+ workspace, which comes in free.
- Match the settings before the numbers. Use the same reference genes, efficiencies and calibrators, then compare the normalized quantities rather than the Cq values.
- Read a difference before trusting either side. Two causes to rule out first: an efficiency typed in one tool and fitted in the other, and another set of reference genes.
What can you keep running beside it?
| Keep in GenEx | PCA and clustering, on the normalized values in Clarida’s Excel notebook |
|---|---|
| Keep in REST 2009 | A quick two-group test, on the notebook’s Cq per well with its sample and target |
| Bring from qbase+ | Whole workspaces, imported free, never counted toward your plan |
| Look at a reaction elsewhere | RDML 1.3 with the raw curves, for RDML-Tools once migrated to 1.4; the file carries no analysis settings |
Frequently asked questions
Is qbase+ still available?
We found no current download when we checked on October 29, 2026. Bio-Rad’s current CFX Maestro bulletin (August 2026) no longer lists the qbase+ license its earlier one bundled, and the US VA’s technical reference calls version 3.2 the most current it knows. If you have a working install, your workspaces import into Clarida free.
Does Clarida have NormFinder, like GenEx?
Yes. Clarida rates reference gene stability with geNorm and NormFinder, and you can compare the two in one experiment. NormFinder is checked against its authors’ Excel add-in on their published example; geNorm’s M values match qbase+.
Do any of these tools plan the experiment?
GenEx helps decide how many replicates to run at which step, from a pilot. The qbase+ manual advises putting as many samples of a gene as you can in one run, with the same three calibrators on every plate where that is impossible. Laying out a plate or working out a mix is documented for none of the three, as of October 26, 2026. In Clarida you list the samples and assays: it lays out the plate by your lab’s rules, gives every mix with its surplus and guides you through filling the wells. It does not estimate how many replicates you need; GenEx goes further there.
Is Clarida a GxP edition, like GenEx GxP?
No. Clarida has no electronic signatures or sign-off, and MultiD sells GenEx GxP as an edition for regulated labs. Clarida stores each setting change, each automatic exclusion and each accepted QC deviation with who and when. A saved analysis is frozen.
What do these tools cost?
REST 2009 is free. GenEx is licensed per user: Thermo Fisher lists GenEx Professional v7.0 at €1,430 for a two-year key, and MultiD gives no price for GenEx 8. Clarida’s free plan: 4 experiments in your first month, then 2 a month. No card. Imported qbase+ workspaces never count toward it; the pricing page has the paid plans.
Sources
Each source with the day we last checked it. Something out of date? Tell us.
- Hellemans et al. (2007), qBase, Genome Biology 8:R19Efficiency-corrected normalization with several reference genes, inter-run calibration, error carried throughChecked October 26, 2026
- Biogazelle, qbasePLUS manual, version 3.2 (2018; Wayback copy of genorm.cmgg.be)Replicate advice, run editor, imports, efficiency, normalization, geNorm, calibration, statistics, exportChecked October 26, 2026
- Bio-Rad, qbasePLUS for CFX (product page)QC, normalization, inter-run calibration, the statistics wizard, RDML export; no ordering shownChecked October 29, 2026
- Bio-Rad, CFX Maestro Software, Bulletin 3971 (August 2026)The current CFX Maestro editions; no qbase+ license listedChecked October 29, 2026
- Bio-Rad, CFX Opus systems, Bulletin 7281 (earlier edition)Bundled a license for qbase+ with CFX Maestro 2.0Checked October 29, 2026
- US Department of Veterans Affairs, Technical Reference Model: qbase+ (updated January 15, 2026)Version 3.2 "the most current known version"; "no recent development activity"Checked October 29, 2026
- CellCarta, acquisition of Biogazelle (December 14, 2021)CellCarta acquired Biogazelle; the release does not mention qbase+Checked October 26, 2026
- MultiD, GenEx 8 and GenEx GxPgeNorm, NormFinder, PCA, self-organizing maps, heat maps; a GxP edition; trial on request, no priceChecked October 29, 2026
- Thermo Fisher, GenEx Professional v7.0 (catalog A33921)€1,430 for one two-year license key, one user; statistics, PCA and heat mapsChecked October 29, 2026
- Pfaffl, GenEx 7.0 product text (gene-quantification.de)A nested ANOVA shows the variance each step adds, to plan replicates; imports the text files cyclers exportChecked October 29, 2026
- QIAGEN, REST 2009 user guide (2009)Cq pasted per gene, efficiency, reference genes, randomization test, box plots; Windows and .NET 2.0Checked October 26, 2026
- Pfaffl, REST 2009 (gene-quantification.de)Free of charge; version 1 of December 22, 2009; a 64-bit patchChecked October 29, 2026
- RDML consortium, RDML-Tools helpOpens RDML 1.4 for a second look at any reaction; RDML-Edit migrates older filesChecked October 26, 2026